I Had No Other Choice

“I had to, I had to, I had no other choice.”

That’s what 15-year-old Kip Kinkel told detectives. The freshman had just killed both his parents before heading to school, where he opened fire in the cafeteria, killing two classmates and injuring 22 others. The trench coat he wore to conceal his weapons later inspired the two killers at Columbine High School, who called themselves the “Trenchcoat Mafia.”

Kip, like the many school shooters who followed, believed that killing was his only option. Do you know what all the school shooters of the 1990s had in common? Aside from being white, suburban males from middle-class families, these young murderers shared three key traits:

1.They obsessively played violent video games and immersed themselves in fantasy culture.

2.They were social outcasts at their schools, often bullied.

3.None attended church or were part of a faith community.

These were not poor, inner-city minorities from single-parent homes strung out on drugs, as some might imagine. Their family structures mirrored those of the general population, with about half coming from divorced or never-married parents. Drug use was only a minor issue in similar proportions. What horrified the nation was not just the shocking form and location of the violence but also the fact that the perpetrators didn’t fit any usual sociological stereotypes.

These shooters seemed like victims of prosperity rather than poverty. 

Fallen cultures produce broken families and weak communities, harvesting vulnerable children who are easily overcome by humanity’s darker tendencies. Vulnerable children are often abused, neglected, abandoned, or maladjusted. Over the decades, America has become increasingly divided into two nations. Sociologist James Q. Wilson describes these two nations in Human Remedies for Social Disorders.

“In one nation, a child is raised by two parents, acquires an education, a job, a spouse, and a home insulated from crime and disorder by distance, fences, or guards. In the other, a child is raised by an unwed mother in a neighborhood filled with transient men but few committed fathers and often finds gang life necessary for self-protection and self-advancement. In the first nation, children look to the future and believe they can shape it; in the second, they live for the moment and think fate, not plans, will dictate their lives.”

I grew up in the second nation—not in an inner city but in poverty-stricken Appalachia. While I didn’t face the scourge of gangs, the rest of Wilson’s description applied to me, my family, and almost everyone I knew.

For the longest time, the second nation (both rural and urban) has been the main breeding ground for vulnerable, distressed, and traumatized children, perpetuating a cycle of harm. However, the first nation is now quickly catching up. Today, we are witnessing the unprecedented unraveling of the first nation.

The first nation now experiences a comparable rate of broken families, but prosperity has largely shielded it from the same consequences. Yet, the caustic influence of our fallen culture is overwhelming even this advantage. In fact, prosperity may be accelerating the decline by providing easier access to poisonous elements of pop culture.

There’s an old saying in the African American community: “When white folks catch a cold, black folks get pneumonia.” While typically used to describe economic downturns, it also applies to cultural toxicity. Divorce, out-of-wedlock births, drug use, and delinquency have fewer negative consequences for the rich than for the poor.

The poor lack the hedge of protection that money, influence, and power provide. A wealthy single mother, for example, may face challenges, but a poor single mother in a blighted neighborhood with few resources will likely face insurmountable battles.

Contrary to common assumptions, children of affluence are not immune. Studies suggest that middle- and upper-class youth are more likely to struggle with substance abuse, anxiety, depression, and eating disorders than their poorer peers. In fact, middle- and upper-class youth have been shown to use drugs at higher rates than those in poverty.

The bottom line is this: our society is in trouble. The tidal wave of hedonism washing over the nation is eroding our cultural foundations, destroying families, and harming children.

What can we do?

Our hope doesn’t lie in sweeping, dramatic solutions or waiting for someone else to fix the problem. There is no grand plan or noble leader who will save us. Cultures change for better or worse through countless small choices made by millions of people.

Every citizen matters, and what every citizen does matters. We can only restore our culture one decision at a time: person by person, family by family, community by community. More tax money and government programs won’t fix this. Governments can transfer money but not transform people. They can build bureaucracies but not strong families.

It will take a massive infusion of common sense and Christian principles to heal the cultural bloodstream. This is like fighting cancer: the cure comes from restoring cell by cell until the whole body is healthy again.

Some blame systemic bigotry or social inequality—race and class—for the struggles of the second nation. I reject that as politically convenient but factually unsound. Long before the second nation was associated with urban minorities, there was white Appalachia, with its deep poverty and cultural backwardness.

White Appalachia has much in common with urban Black communities but little in common with white suburbia. The struggles of both groups are rooted in cultural decay, not racial or class divides. And now, the first nation, with its advantages of wealth and power, is succumbing to the same destructive forces. Prosperity can no longer prevent the profound erosion of cultural values.

For decades, we’ve tried to merge these two nations by changing everything except the family. We’ve transferred wealth to make poverty more bearable. We’ve built public housing, distributed food stamps, and funded countless programs. Still, the two nations persist.

The family is at the heart of this divide. Children are not raised by programs or governments but by two parents fervently devoted to their well-being. Yet many children, especially in some communities, are raised by one parent. Our goal shouldn’t be to expand the welfare state. It has already done immense damage, decimating families—particularly the role of fathers. Good intentions aren’t enough; results matter more.

America has weathered existential threats before. We can survive this too, but only if we reverse these troubling trends. No nation, no matter how rich, can endure the simultaneous loss of family and a rising tide of hedonism. Overcoming this “perfect storm” requires a grand vision and unwavering commitment to the long haul.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share the Post:

Related Posts